WCO#237: Redd

wcotitle-v4a

In hero fiction, losing an appendage is never the end of the world. In fact, it is an opportunity for more adventure. A missing hand, for example, and be replaced by some sort of robot prothetics, like a claw that can crush through solid metal or a pop-up sword. As a child, who among us didn’t pretend to retract their hands into their long sweater sleeve, then pretend that what came out was a massive Gatling gun, poised to mow down the enemy forces that exist only in a child’s brutal imagination? PVC tubing or bendy straws may have been involved.

Hence, you have a host of super tough dudes who have amazing prosthetics. You’ve got Cable, a beefy mountain of a man who has one metal arm. Surprisingly, he doesn’t tip over or develop back pains. You’ve got Robocop, who’s sort of a jumble of replacement limbs, including a leg that awesomely contains a gun holster. Awesome robo-appendages can also be found on the ladies, such as Kimiko Ross from the webcomic Dresden Codak.

However, all those assume that the characters were born with functional arms and/or legs. What about characters who never had such a luxury? Maybe flippers hands or … perhaps … not even having arms at all? Where is the superhero for the handicapped… or rather, the handi-capable?

What’s that? Up in the sky! It’s a bird! It’s a … plane that seems to be missing its wings! It’s Redd!

012

That’s right, readers. Redd is a superhero with no arms and also no clothes. Because while she may not have been born with limbs, at least she was born with the things that did matter: her jugs and her legs. Amirite, fellas? You know what I’m talking about. She does have two red robot hands, though, which float around her basically in around the same position if she had arms. It’s sort of a phantom limb thing, like that Venture Bros. character of the same name.

Which brings to mind a question: if you were a scientist developing these cool new appendages for Redd, why wouldn’t you give her actual arms? Throughout the comic, I was sorta wondering if maybe there were complications because Redd wasn’t born with arms. Like, she would really know how to use limbs if she’d lived all hear life without them. Maybe the floating robo-hands were easier to use? But, wait, later we see her in disguise deploying an arrangement of six workable arms. So… it is possible for Redd to not look so dang weird, flying around in the sky with no arms nor care in the world.

Redd works for some sort of scientific organization that provides her upgrades, knick-knacks, and other sorts of technical doo-dads. They provide, for example, her skintight outfit, which can withstand cannon fire. Now I know what you’re saying. “Taking cannonballs to the gut? Is she joining the circus?” Alas, this is not to be. Under the direction of some creepy looking bosses, Redd fights sea monsters looking to put a bite into urban areas. It’s pretty much Evangelion, but without the minimalist Angel designs or the cleverness.

004-4

The fights are not very well drawn. Most are over after three pages, with the monsters barely putting up a fight. In fact, I’m pretty sure they never put any offense in. One sea monster does smack Redd around, but for the life of me it looks like that she’s running into it. I get the impression that if Redd had done nothing and left well enough alone, these monsters would probably just hung out on the beach, catching some rays.

What Redd wants to be, though, is a superhero. But wait. She’s already fighting giant monsters, and she can fly and has super strength? Isn’t she a superhero already? Well, apparently this webcomic tries to redefine what a superhero is. Out are urban vigilantes like Spider-Man and Batman. These heroes are “contractual city protection.” Redd’s organization has a very poor view of them, seeing them as narcissistic egomaniacs. Redd gets treated to a rant worthy of Image Comics from the early 90’s:

You see why the country wants you to deal with him. The proper superheroes keep locking him up, and he keeps getting out again. They allow these tragedies to keep happening to sate their self-imposed moralities. There’s nothing moral about allowing this to keep happening, Redd. People want to bring back corporal punishment just for this guy. But supervillains get supervillain prisons, outside the government’s authority. That’s why we need to get him first. So these supers can’t keep playing their game with innocent people.

004

It probably would have helped the organization’s case if we’d seen a supervillain doing horrible things. All we get is a scene where he shows up for the fight (which, like the sea monster fight, is more about Redd bumping into things). Like, why do people want to bring corporal punishment back for this one guy? Did he level a city? Is he like the Joker, kidnapping and torturing people? I’m not saying that these need to be drawn. Before I’m convinced, I think there needs to be more detail and evidence than “this guy is bad and the superheroes are on an ego trip”.

It doesn’t matter to Redd, though! While she initially hesitates over the idea of killing another human being, that little pep talk was enough for her to Otherwise, Redd looks like a total and utter idiot when she goes all sickhouse on the bad guy. It’s less a fight and more of an execution; like the sea monsters, her adversary never gets a blow in. She kills the poorly defined menace while a shocked superhero looks on.

Our hero, ladies and gentlemen!

And, just to make Redd look even more like an easily led moron, there’s a very good chance that Redd’s organization isn’t quite entirely on the level. Her superiors look kinda sketchy, and the organization is pretty obviously patterned around SEELE from Evangelion. So, probably not the good guys.

The superheroes and supervillains aren’t necessarily the good guys, either. (Though, from what we see of the superheroes, they look like a group of nice kids and not the ego-obsessed showboaters that Redd’s organization portrays them as.) Now, we’re meant to buy that what Redd did — executing a supervillain — was at least partially justified. The ultimate motivation of her organization my be murky, but the villain was supposed to be a legit bad dude that the public wanted dead. The united heroes and villains don’t seem to think of it that way, though, and they send someone to confront her. Someone who… kinda looks like the grim reaper. I’m guessing we’re not meant to root for the scary skull-faced guys who threaten limbless girls.

003-2

A disturbing amount of panels and dialogue is devoted to what Redd is wearing. While the fights are glossed over and uninteresting, the various outfits of Redd are discussed energetically and enthusiastically. It starts off innocently enough with the spandex power armor. That makes sense, right? What separates that scene in Iron Man, where Tony Stark works in his garage to develop the perfect armor? Nothing. But then it gets a little ridiculous. Like when she’s lounging around in lingerie for a completely unnecessary scene. Or why she wears a sundress to battle. Our how one skimpy bikini makes her look like a character in a Korean MMORPG. Heck, even baggy sweaters cannot pass without comment. Redd is pretty much a limbless paper dress up doll.

Do you think that’s what inspired Redd? Like, the person who created it was cutting out one of those paper dolls from a dollar store coloring book. (Or pound store book; I suspect that the creator is from the UK somewhere.) Suddenly, the scissors slip, and they accidentally cut off one of the arms! Rather than be broken-hearted though, he thinks wistfully, “What are your adventures, limbless girl? Would you be fighting sea monsters? Would you be a superhero?” And then he glances at the cute sundress outfit next to her, and the gears in his brain start spinning like crazy.

Who am I kidding. We all know why this webcomic was made. One the one had, I guess it’s a little refreshing that there’s a guy out there who’s hoping to meet the armless girl of his dreams. On the other hand… well, look at the sample images I posted in this review. It’s … kinda fetishistic.

Rating: 2 Stars (out of 5)

About these ads

About El Santo

Somehow ended up reading and reviewing almost 300 different webcomics. Life is funny, huh? Despite owning two masks, is not actually a luchador.

Posted on February 19, 2014, in 2 Stars, action webcomic, superheroes, The Webcomic Overlook, WCO Big Review, webcomics. Bookmark the permalink. 13 Comments.

  1. Oof, fanservice ahoy. It looks like they opted to make her armless so her limbs would not get in the way of her tits. I like the basic idea though.

    • I agree. Some very interesting ideas, like how a person who has had neural prostheses her entire life would be better at using brain-linked weapons, and the idea of a corporation making more reliable superheroes (like a profit-minded version of Syndrome from The Incredibles). Also, the faces are expressive, and it makes great use of perspective in the art.

      I kept reading, hoping it would get less fanservice/less fetishistic, but it just kept ramping it up until it lost me.

  2. All I can think while viewing this is at least learn how to draw breasts before making a character that is 90% breasts.

  3. I think its safe to say this is a fetish comic disguised as a superhero-comic rather than the other way around.

    • Yeah, this comic falls firmly into the “thinly veiled fetish material” category for me, too. In fact, I’m a little surprised El Santo even bothered to review this, given his general policy against reviewing porn/fetish comics.

      • Porn comics, no. Fetish comics? … as it turns out, sometimes. I did review Las Lindas, after all.

        And Least I Could Do, now that I think of it.

        EDIT: let’s just put it this way — if any comic review site ever put the brakes on anything that was somewhat fetishistic, there would be nothing to review. The “Dark Phoenix Saga” is one of the most celebrated storylines in print comics, for example… and at the center of it is The White Queen, who’s dressed in a corset, underwear, and thigh high stockings. (Apparently Chris Claremont was way into “the scene.”)

        • Dont forget Shädbase which is a profilic porn artist’s attempt at doing video game humor, Jack (the bunny one, also one of the funniest reviews on this site), Grim Tales, Banzai Girl, Blade Bunny and Boss Noodle.

          Given how these fetish comics seem to share the same problems, I wonder if theres any fetish webcomic out there which can actually be considered “good”, despite being fetishistic as all hell. No doubt theres plenty of webcomics out there which began as fetish comics but became good later on or vice versa, but I struggle to think of a webcomic- or a comic out there that can be classified as a fetish comic but one which still manages to be good, so other than the fetishists could also enjoy it.

          • Well Oglaf is just a straight up porn comic, not a fetsih one, but that’s prety good. Also don’t be so harsh on Blade Bunny, it has a lot ofcheescake but that hardly makesit a fetish comic.

          • Well, I suppose a fetish comic could be good if it explored its core subject, rather than just focusing on being porn. I recall a series of BDSM themed gag comics that poked fun at fetish-focused slice of life situations. For instance, the main character’s friends are discussing how they went sporting, and they have all sorts of aches, but it was a lot of fun. Then they call her crazy when she says she had her butt spanked, because you have to be crazy to willfully subject yourself to pain. That’s an interesting juxtaposition that puts the fetish in perspective.

            And to be fair, I don’t think anyone ever broke a leg while doing BDSM. Can’t say the same about sports.

          • … one which still manages to be good, so other than the fetishists could also enjoy it.

            I don’t know if that’s really possible – I mean, a fetish comic is more or less by definition going to focus on material that non-fetishists will generally find uninteresting at best, and outright offensive at worst.

            For example, while I can recognize that a comic like, say, Eerie Cuties is competently drawn and written, I don’t read that comic because, frankly, I find the transformation fetish stuff incredibly off-putting.

  4. Well, a few manga came to mind, Hentai Kamen which uses its themes of BDSM for dark humor, and Gunsmith Cats which had the usual panty shots and all that, and despite being embarrassed about them (and creeped out by some of the underage sex stuff) I remember really liking them regardless, since they also had some great action storytelling to them. Car chases were engaging and gave the reader a sense of speed to it which is really hard to do in a comic, gunplay was also like in some detective movie from the 80’s, in a good way.

    And now that I think about it, I could live with the fact Redd is a fetish comic if it would have a better overall story to it, better storytelling, more complex and more engaging action to it, art-wise more emphasis on the surroundings (though the characters look alright, lot of the backrounds are just outright lazy, any good action should give you the sense of speed and space, and doing panels which put their emphasis on showing where everything is happening can help a lot in that).

    Fetish alone shouldnt be able to put off readers if its just inserted carefully enough. Take for example Hitchcock’s and his wive’s unhealty obsession towards blonde women. You can clearly see why so many women in his movies are blonde but he’s professional enough to make sure the story and the storytelling didnt suffer because of it.

  5. Redd gives me this vague uneasy feeling of an artist with a Rayman fetish.

  6. Have you ever thought about adding a little bit more than just your articles?
    I mean, what you say iis fundamental and everything.

    However think of if you added somme great
    images or videos to give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellenmt butt with images and clips,
    this site could definitely be oone off the very best in its niche.

    Superb blog!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: