One Punch Reviews #24: A.D.: New Orleans After the Deluge
August 11, 2009 at 3:39 pm | Posted in 5 Stars, One Punch Reviews, The Webcomic Overlook, dramatic webcomic, historical webcomic, real life webcomic, slice-of-life webcomic, webcomics | 8 CommentsTags: AD: New Orleans After the Deluge, Hurricane Katrina
It’s not often that webcomics tackle serious subject matter. It’s even rarer when creators take the time to interview people who lived through traumatic real world events, then captured their experiences through illustrations. Creator Josh Neufeld, though, a Xeric Award winner and a founding member of ACT-I-VATE, was up to the task. Neufeld interviewed six different people about what the trials and tribulations they faced on the worst storm that New Orleans ever experienced and made a comic out of it.
This month, the highly acclaimed webcomic A.D.: New Orleans After the Deluge hits the bookshelves. (Amazon.com places the release date at August 18.) The “deluge” in the title is, of course, Hurricane Katrina. The comic was originally serialized online between 2007 and 2008 in Smith Magazine. It was recognized in several publications, including Rolling Stone, the LA Times, the Wall Street Journal, and Newsweek. USA Today named it as one of 2007′s best comics.
Notices like these, by the way, can sometimes be detrimental. They can intimidate potential readers who see the attention the comic is getting from mainstream media reviewers and deduce that the work is difficult, given how praise is usually only bestowed to difficult works. Well, don’t be frightened. The voices of A.D. are those of everyday people, and the straight forward storytelling puts you in the shoes of those who witnessed it.
A.D.: New Orleans After the Deluge
A.D. doesn’t take political sides … not overtly, anyway. There are times when the comic is filled with outbursts of anger at the mismanagement of the evacuation and rampant speculation about a conspiracy to wipe out the poor. The accusations, however, are outbursts from people who are tired, thirsty, and exhausted. People who were herded into a crowded encampment that, in many cases, was worse and more dangerous than the houses they just abandoned. You can hardly blame them for being paranoid.
When you get past the cinematic prologues, which depict the full fury of the storm, A.D. begins rather low-key. New Orleans residents have heard the news of the coming storm, and they are waiting to see what to do next. There’s a general air of dismissal. Hurricanes have come close in the past, but they’ve never done serious harm to New Orleans. A shopkeeper stays behind to protect his shop. A man and his wife leave most of their possessions at home, fully expecting to return soon. A doctor decides to stay behind at a restaurant, expecting to ride out the storm.
And then it begins to rain. And then the levees break. And the story builds up to a crescendo of chaos and uncertainty as the unstoppable force of nature changes New Orleans forever. Unlike the prologue, we see things from the eyes of those who lived it.
Neufeld uses colors sparingly and to great effect. It’s a black-and-white comic, or more precisely two washed out color tones. This simple style effectively sparks the senses. As we watch two men lying on the shed behind their store, we feel their chills and the sickness. A restaurant, spared form the floods but without electricity, feels musty and dank. Later, as we watch a mass of humanity crowd around a convention center, the yellows and oranges remind you of the sickening heat and thick, muggy atmosphere.
Some of the experiences are harrowing. One woman holds on to her life as strong winds smash through her windows. Others are smaller and more personal losses, like when a man realizes that his prized comic book collection has been destroyed by the flood. I was personally drawn to the story of Hamid and Mansell. They were given an opportunity by a passing Samaritan in a motorboat to leave for safety. They stayed behind, however, to defend the goods from looters — looters that never came, and goods that would soon spoil due to the lack of power and the rising floodwaters.
The most remarkable thing about A.D. is that is may be the most honest and candid account about Hurricane Katrina that you’ll find in any medium. There’s an absence of the more sensational stories, such as the alleged incidents in the Superdome. Rather, we see people simply trying to survive, and later, move on. Neufeld interviews the subjects at one year intervals after the Hurricane. We get to see how adversity changes people, but it doesn’t destroy them. We also see the charity and goodness shine through. One woman starts counseling Katrina survivors. The comic book fan’s library is rebuilt through the contributions of generous individuals who heard about his plight through his blog.
I hear that the book offers 25% new content. It’s a great way to support Josh Neufeld, who should rightfully be compensated for this project. However, the webcomic is indispensable. Below the illustrated panels are links to audio and video clips of the people featured in the comic, blogs, photo essays, and newspaper articles. Admittedly, I haven’t clicked on many of them, but I do plan on doing so when I revisit the comic in the future. It’s a fine example as to how comics can aspire to be more than just entertainment, and also how comic’s don’t have to be hemmed to the sequential panels. Comics — webcomics in particular — can be the very voice of history.
Rating: 5 stars (out of 5)
8 Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
WCO Central
-
Recent Comments
Featured Products
Amazon.com links
Mystery Science Theater 3000: The Movie (Widescreen): MST3K: The Movie is back ... and on DVD! If you haven't seen it yet, you must check it out. If you've seen it 15 times ... well, that Rando joke never gets old.
The Perry Bible Fellowship: The Trial of Colonel Sweeto and Other Stories: One of the most highly acclaimed webcomics in print form! Great art and dark yet surprisingly subtle humor.
Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art: Scott McCloud's influential guide on what makes comics tick!
Gunnerkrigg Court: Orientation: Tom Siddell's amazing comic of magic, whimsy, and steampunk robots.
Achewood: The Great Outdoor Fight: The legendary Achewood story arc.
Blog at WordPress.com. | Theme: Pool by Borja Fernandez.
Entries and comments feeds.
[...] [Review] A.D.: New Orleans After the Deluge Link: Larry Cruz [...]
Pingback by Journalista - the news weblog of The Comics Journal » Blog Archive » Aug. 12, 2009: Blame — August 12, 2009 #
Neat. I’ll have to check this one out. I’m a sap for good memoir and biographical type comics. Maus was really what got me into comics and I still like that sort of thing.
Comment by Quijotesca — August 12, 2009 #
[...] about A.D.: New Orleans After the Deluge with John Hogan at Graphic Novel Reporter, and Larry Cruz reviews the print edition at The Webcomic [...]
Pingback by Digital Strips: The Webcomics Podcast : Links: Summer reading edition — August 12, 2009 #
[...] MPD57 reviewed Physikon, Bow & Arrow Detective Agency, Cards Kill and Absolute Magnitude while If You See The Hills gets pushed off the ledge by Pigs Of The Industry – who also covered Arctic, Antique Books and Octane Jungle. You can get an overview of the August Star Chamber results at MPD57. This Week In Webcomics posted a review of Marooned just before press time last Friday and Tangents is inviting guest reviews for October. Webcomic Overlook reviewed A.D.: New Orleans After The Deluge. [...]
Pingback by Strip News 8-14-9 | Strip News | ArtPatient.com | ArtPatient.com — August 14, 2009 #
[...] like Flavorpill’s “FlavorWire,” MTV’s “SplashPage,” TakePart, WebComicOverlook, Deckfight, ICv2, and PopTheology covering the [...]
Pingback by On-Sale Date | A.D.: New Orleans After The Deluge — August 18, 2009 #
[...] Neufeld goes on tour to promote A.D.: New Orleans After The Deluge (reviewed here), which just became available in book form. Important piece for y’all in the Pacific [...]
Pingback by The Dog Days of Joy of Webcomics « The Webcomic Overlook — August 20, 2009 #
[...] The article offers tough criticism of the comic, which may be warranted (although here’s a more thoughtful piece that offers a different assessment) but then goes on to give the stank eye to all recent non-fiction [...]
Pingback by TBoH Rant: Newsweek’s Review of Hurricane Katrina Comic « The Bottom of Heaven — August 22, 2009 #
[...] representing webcomics: Josh Neufeld’s A.D.: New Orleans After the Deluge (reviewed here) — which began its life as a webcomic and went on to garner critical acclaim from Wired, [...]
Pingback by The 2010 Eisner Nominations have arrived! « The Webcomic Overlook — April 8, 2010 #